WILDERNESS MEDICINE
From the 22nd Annual National Conference on Wilderness Medicine, presented by the American College of
Emergency Physicians (ACEP), the ACEP State Chapter of California, Inc, and Wilderness and Travel Medicine
Howard J. Donner, MD, Napa, CA
Educational Objectives
| The goals of this program are to improve the management of infections and other illnesses that can occur during
backcountry expeditions and to improve the disinfection of water during these trips. After hearing and assimilating
this program, the clinician will be better able to:
|
 | Provide pain relief and treat respiratory, gastrointestinal, and soft tissue infections, with special considerations
for longer trips and tropical destinations.
|
 | Manage reactive airway disease, epistaxis, and cardiovascular problems.
|
 | Discuss treatment of gynecologic problems that may arise on longer expeditions.
|
 | Distinguish between sterilization, disinfection, and clarification of water, and cite basic methodology for each
process.
|
 | Assess the advantages and disadvantages of various commercially available water, purification and disinfection
systems.
|
Faculty Disclosure
In adherence to ACCME Standards for Commercial Support, Audio-Digest requires all faculty and members of the
planning committee to disclose relevant financial relationships within the past 12 months that might create any personal
conflicts of interest. Any identified conflicts were resolved to ensure that this educational activity promotes
quality in health care and not a proprietary business or commercial interest. For this program, Dr. Donner and the
planning committee reported nothing to disclose.
Acknowledgments
Dr. Donner was recorded at the 22nd Annual National Conference on Wilderness Medicine, held August 6-10, 2008,
in Big Sky, MT, and sponsored by the American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP), the ACEP State Chapter
of California, Inc, and Wilderness and Travel Medicine. The Audio-Digest Foundation thanks Dr. Donner and the
sponsors for their cooperation in the production of this program.
Expedition Medicine and Backcountry Medical Kits
| Common components of kit: splint, duct tape, and elastic bandage (ACE-type wrap; will not stabilize blown-out
joint but will provide compression); rest, ice, compression, elevationrest, ice, and elevation difficult on expeditions;
ACE-type wrap helps hold adhesive tape in wilderness; nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs); tell
travelers what to bringbandages, NSAIDs, blister treatments (helps keep expedition medical kit more organized)
|
| Pain relief: always be prepared to relieve pain; acetaminophen with codeinenot always effective; can have high
side effect profile; make your own decision on pain relief; NSAIDconsider bringing something with less frequent
dosing (eg, naproxen [eg, Naprosyn] or celecoxib [Celebrex]) for patients requiring long-term treatment; narcotic
by mouthnew buccal fentanyl tablet (Fentora) dissolves in mouth (equivalent to intravenous [IV] dose of
fentanyl); reports of death in patients in whom drug contraindicated
|
| Infections: bring antibiotics for main organ systems affected by infection, ie, respiratory, gastrointestinal [GI], or soft
tissue
|
 | Respiratory: azithromycineffective; possibly overused; compact; requires few tablets (compliance key on expeditions);
low side effect profile; amoxicillinpotassium clavulanate (Augmentin)certain subset of patients allergic;
consider drugs that work best for most people; azithromycin (Z-pack)expensive (some use samples);
effective
|
 | Gastrointestinal: ciprofloxacin (eg, Cipro)second-generation fluoroquinolone; well tested; works well for some
diarrheas; third- and fourth-generation drugs may have better gram-positive and anaerobic coverage
|
 | Soft tissue: speaker used to carry cephalexin (Keflex); if concerned about community-acquired methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) infection, start patients on trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (TMP-SMZ; eg, Septra)
|
 | Tropical areas and longer trips: consider doxycycline; used for leptospirosis; useful in remote exotic areas; when
someone has fever of unknown origin far away from laboratory; diarrheaGiardia lamblia often not an issue
on shorter trips; for longer trips, carry tinidazole; tinidazole (eg, Tindamax) works better than metronidazole; 2-
dose regimen; nitazoxanidealternative to tinidazole
|
| Airway problems: common for patients to develop reactive airway component with upper respiratory infection
(upper or lower tract); wheezing and frequent coughing; use bronchodilators (eg, albuterol) instead of cough
medicines
|
 | Epistaxis: oxymetazoline (eg, Afrin); have patient blow out blood clot before applying nasal decongestant (vasoconstricts);
have patient sit down (not lie down), and apply gentle pressure (15-20 min); if nose continues bleeding,
use nasal tampons (eg, Rhino Rockets); lubricate them to start expansion or spray extra oxymetazoline; start
antibiotics; many primary care physicians remove tampons too early (leave in 48 hr)
|
 | Corticosteroids: prednisone; inexpensive, small, and lightweight; effective for poison oak or ivy and asthma exacerbations
(if patient runs out of metered dose inhaler)
|
 | Cough: carry cough drops (eg, Ricola)
|
| Tips for crossing borders: no absolute solutions; do not carry white powder in plastic bag; keep medicines organized
(plastic bags acceptable); prevent medicine from getting crushed or wet; prepare individually organized and labeled
kit; bring copy of medical license; print formalized letter of introduction on high-quality stationery, including details
of trip
|
| Central nervous system conditions: sedationstress of trip, life transitions, and homesickness can cause transient
anxiety, depression, or psychosis; alertnessbring caffeine pill (eg, NoDoz) for all-night rescues and caffeine
withdrawal (treat headache with ibuprofen); modafinil (eg, Provigil) commonly used for maintaining alertness (not
for caffeine withdrawal); expensive; sedative hypnoticalprazolam (eg, Xanax) preferred by speaker
|
| Cardiovascular problems: technologic advances now make monitoring patients possible; now carrying advanced
cardiac life support (ACLS) kits; nitratesfor probable cardiac symptoms described by patient as indigestion;
determine contraindications (eg, congestive heart failure, cardiogenic shock); acceptable for most middle-aged
adults; for long transports, use transdermal nitrates (more portable); β-blockersuse what you use in emergency
department (ED); reduce myocardial oxygen demand; aspirincan save lives; important to bring for angina or
chest pain
|
| Gynecology: reproductive-aged women can die from complications of first trimester pregnancy; on longer trips, most
important medical consideration; female trekker with vaginal blood spotting and lower abdominal pain
administer pregnancy test (urine beta human chorionic gonadotropin [ βhCG]); if positive, assume ectopic pregnancy
until ruled out; if negative, wait few days (could be mittelschmerz, hemorrhagic cysts, or others); longer
tripsbring high-estrogen oral contraceptives (OCs) for dysfunctional uterine bleeding (DUB); hormonally cycles
these patients (after 7 days, continue normal dose of OCs or withdraw OC); withdrawal bleeding common; DUB
usually stops; do not use high-estrogen OC in βhCG-positive patients; yeast infectionscommon on expeditions because
diarrhea common and antibiotic use frequent; fluconazole (eg, Diflucan) recommended; takes effect after 1 to
3 days; treat local inflammation with topical steroids (instead of specific anti-yeast creams)
|
| GI disorders: constipationcommon on long trips; often due to diet changes; add fiber to diet as prophylaxis; hydrate
patients to treat; bring bran or fiber supplement (eg, Metamucil) and laxative of choice; sports fluidssource
of electrolytes for long-duration activity; important for prolonged diarrhea, vomiting, and blood loss; oral rehydration
salts (ORS) commonly available in remote areas; dilute sports drinks 1:1 with water; new formulation for reduced
osmolarity ORS (World Health Organization recommendations)
|
| Blisters: blister plasters (eg, Compeed)recommended for complicated blisters; sticks well; blister prevention aids
(eg, Blist-O-Ban)creates artificial plastic bubble that helps reduce friction
|
Backcountry Water Purification
| Sterilization and disinfection: nothing important about water boiling point; most enteric pathogens have thermal
death points far below boiling; sterilizeremove all biologic materials (including bacterial spores); disinfectremove
enteric pathogens; pasteurization of milk and dairy products150o F for longer time kills all pathogens; bottom
linesufficient to bring water to boil; altitudefor 5000 to 15000 ft, water boiling temperature 185o F (well
above temperatures used in pasteurization); altitude usually not problematic until 20000 ft; at sea level, bring water
to boil; 10000 ft, add few more minutes of boiling; heatdoes not change taste; consider environmental implications
of using local wood
|
| Water clarification: sedimentationlet water sit (overnight); coagulation-flocculationused for removing suspended
solids rapidly; works well; requires aluminum potassium sulfate (alum); mix alum (one-eighth to one-
fourth teaspoon per gallon water); in minutes, flocculants form and coagulate sediments; filter (can use coffee filter);
does not disinfect (might reduce microbial load); granular activated charcoal (GAC)works well for removing
organic pollutants (not heavy metals); removes taste, odor, and color; good for clarification; can be used in
conjunction with halogenation
|
| Halogenation: first-order reaction kinetics (ie, can decrease amount of halogen and increase contact time);
sensitivitybacteria very sensitive; viruses moderately sensitive; protozoan cysts (Giardia lamblia and
Cryptosporidium parvum) somewhat resistant (even to newer forms of halogen, including chlorine dioxide); temperature
dependencecold water slows reaction, so increase contact time or concentration; free residual
halogensorganic pollutants (eg, carbohydrates) bind free iodine, leaving less free halogen for disinfection; if flavoring
water with sports fluid, do so after iodination; always wait for full contact time (typically 30-60 min); cloudy
water (higher organic load)double dose of halogen; alkaline waterincrease concentration or contact time;
reduce bad taste (from iodine-based halogens)allow normal contact time, then use activated charcoal filter or
ascorbic acid tablets (sold in backpacking stores and pharmacies)
|
 | Chlorine vs iodine: chlorineolder method; poor taste; less effective against protozoal cysts; short shelf-life; iodine
generally better; still poorly effective against protozoal cysts
|
 | Halogenation products: iodine crystals (eg, Polar Pure) add crystals and water to glass bottle to create saturated
iodine solution; allow time to dissolve, then decant solution from bottle; can disinfect 2000 L; glass bottle necessary
because crystals caustic (inconvenient on trips); some people worry about ingesting crystals; tincture of
iodineavailable in many developing areas; consult textbook of wilderness medicine for dose
|
 | Povidone iodine (eg, Betadine): appropriate in certain situations (eg, when filter breaks); 10% povidone-iodine
use 4 to 8 drops/L with 30-min contact time (under normal conditions)
|
 | Iodine toxicity: avoid in persons with thyroid disease and in pregnancy; studies examining long-term ingestion
show subtle changes in thyrotropin (probably not significant in healthy people); most experts advise limiting iodine
use to 1 to 4 wk; no known maximum dose, but limit whenever possible
|
 | Chlorine dioxide: new halogen compound with advantages over chlorine and iodine (eg, more effective against
Cryptosporidium; better tasting); stability issues (discard after 1 yr); speaker recommends; does not affect thyroid;
new single-agent forms provide better stability; many preparations formerly made with iodine (eg, Potable
Aqua) now also made with chlorine dioxide
|
| Water filters: highly effective against protozoa (eg, Cryptosporidium, Giardia) because of large size (compared to
bacteria); viruses not amenable to filtration alone (in most cases); most filters inadequate for developing countries
where viral diseases, eg, poliomyelitis, still of concern; when shopping for filtersconsider size, weight, ease of
pumping, ease of cleaning, output (for your group), and typical life; compare pore size using absolute (not nominal)
measures; iodinated resinsused as final stage of filtration process; United States Environmental Protection
Agency has removed some resins from market (unable to prove contact time adequate for disinfection); resins probably
inadequate for removal of viruses; complete water purifier system (Sawyer)uses dialysis filters; large surface
area; small pumping force required; can filter by sucking through straw; effective for virus removal; may be
caveats; provides complete disinfection
|
| Filtration of viruses: chlorine dioxide-based formula (eg, ViralStop)used as second step in filtration procedure;
first filter to remove protozoa and bacteria; then use ViralStop for viruses; reduced contact time (5-15 min), compared
to chlorine dioxide without prefiltration (4 hr)
|
| New disinfection system: mixed oxidant disinfectant pen (Miox)electrolysis reaction in rock salt creates mixed
oxidant solution which is used to disinfect water; likely includes chlorine dioxide and other oxidants; effective
against Cryptosporidium; takes 4 hr; weighs 8 oz; expensive ($130); requires batteries, test strips, and salt tablets
|
| UV treatment: used for municipal water treatment for decades; miniature UV disinfection systems now made for
backcountry; SteriPENprimary product sold in backpacking stores; works for relatively small amounts of water;
easily broken; requires batteries; consider for soft adventure trips; new models made for more rugged use; solar-
powered chargers available; solar disinfection (SODIS)water goes into plastic bottle containing UV element;
does not work for turbid or cloudy water; website (http://www.sodis.ch/)explains solar water disinfection for
large municipal water supplies using clear soft drink bottles placed on rooftops
|
| Question and answer: do rivers or lakes contain cleaner water? studies of pathogen load indicate lakes contain
cleaner water; decant water from first 6 to 10 in of lake water (may be purified by UV light)
|
Suggested Reading
Auerbach PS: The relevance and future of wilderness medicine. Travel Med Infect Dis 3:179, 2005; Burdick TE:
Wilderness event medicine: planning for mass gatherings in remote areas. Travel Med Infect Dis 3:249, 2005; Derlet
RW: Backpacking in Yosemite and Kings Canyon National Parks and neighboring wilderness areas: how safe is the
water to drink? J Travel Med 15:209, 2008; Derlet RW et al: Risk factors for coliform bacteria in backcountry lakes
and streams in the Sierra Nevada mountains: a 5-year study. Wilderness Environ Med 19:82, 2008; Diallo MB et al:
GIS-based analysis of the fate of waste-related pathogens Cryptosporidium parvum, Giardia lamblia and Escherichia
coli in a tropical canal network. J Water Health 7:133, 2009; Godfrey S et al: Analysis of enterococci using portable
testing equipment for developing countries: variance of Azide NutriDisk medium under variable time and temperature.
Water Sci Technol 54:127, 2006; Guerrero-Lillo L et al: Knowledge, attitudes, and practices evaluation about travel
medicine in international travelers and medical students in Chile. J Travel Med 16:60, 2009; Hill LC et al: Energy balance
during backpacking. Int J Sports Med 29:883, 2008; Reilly T et al: The use of recovery methods post-exercise. J
Sports Sci 23:619, 2005; Townes DA: Wilderness medicine. Prim Care 29:1027, 2002.
|