DEVELOPMENTAL PSYCHOPATHOLOGY AND EATING DISORDERS
From the 34th Annual Family Medicine Review Course, presented June 10-13, 2008, by the University of Vermont
College of Medicine
Educational Objectives
| The goal of this program is to improve the understanding of childhood psychopathology and the management of
eating disorders (EDs). After hearing and assimilating this program, the clinician will be better able to:
|
 | 1. Describe the role of genetics and environment on the development of psychiatric illness in children.
|
 | 2. Discuss the effect of negative environmental stimuli on examples of genotypes.
|
 | 3. Take a family-based approach in the management of psychiatric illnesses in children.
|
 | 4. Identify triggers and patterns in patients with EDs.
|
 | 5. Navigate through various levels of care to optimize recovery in patients with an ED.
|
Faculty Disclosure
In adherence to ACCME Standards for Commercial Support, Audio-Digest requires all faculty and members of the planning
committee to disclose relevant financial relationships within the past 12 months that might create any personal conflicts of interest.
Any identified conflicts were resolved to ensure that this educational activity promotes quality in health care and not a proprietary
business or commercial interest. For this program, the faculty and planning committee reported nothing to disclose.
Acknowledgements
Dr. Hudziak, Dr. Rettew, and Ms. Bove spoke in South Burlington, VT, at the 34th Annual Family Medicine Review
Course, presented June 10-13, 2008, by the University of Vermont College of Medicine. The Audio-Digest Foundation
thanks the speakers and the University of Vermont College of Medicine for their cooperation in the production of
this program.
Genetic and Environmental Influences on Developmental Psychopathology
James J. Hudziak, MD, Professor of Psychiatry, Medicine, and Pediatrics, and Thomas M. Achenbach Chair in Developmental
Psychopathology, University of Vermont College of Medicine, and Director, Vermont Center for Children,
Youth, and Families, Burlington
| Introduction: 80% of adults who suffer from psychiatric illness had onset of illness in childhood; understanding
of adult psychopathology requires some understanding of developmental psychopathology; 33% of adult patients
have psychiatric illness (occupy 50% of office visits)
|
| Brain development: in children 3 yr of age, frontal part of brain (responsible for reasoning and executive processing)
has not begun to myelinate; formations start to take place by 6 yr of age (most children able to sit still
and pay attention; this is why I dont diagnose and treat attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder [ADHD] before
age 5 yr); in adulthood (age 28-30 yr), prefrontal and orbital frontal cortical regions begin to form (development
of executive processing and problem-solving ability); processes under genetic control; genes, brain development,
and behavior affected by environment (eg, nurturing or abuse); during first 10 yr of life, superior
intelligence accounted for by rate of rapid cortical thickening, followed by rapid cortical thinning; study saw development
of cortical mantle in child 13 yr of age with ADHD similar to that of child 10 yr of age without
ADHD; possibly up to 3 yr between development of cortical processes of prefrontal cortex in children with
ADHD and children without ADHD
|
| Genetics: all human diseases complex content-dependent entities to which genes make necessary (but only partial)
contribution; new geneticsmay affect medicine, psychiatry, and society; identification of genes that increase
risk for illness by 3% to 5%; genes alone may not be harmful; rather, interaction with negative environmental
stimuli may increase risk for disorder
|
| Human genome: genome sequencing services available; consists of 3.15 billion chemical bases; changes in genetic
code, amino acids, and proteins can lead to illness; 22q11.2 deletion or velocardiofacial syndromecan
result in cleft palate or lip, cardiopathology, or phenotypic variant; almost all such patients have ADHD in
childhood; most patients smoke tobacco; 30% develop schizophrenia
|
 | Catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) genotype: COMT regulates dopamine in prefrontal cortex; COMT subtype
with valine (Val) isoform has 4 times more enzymatic activity than that with methionine (Met) isoform
(may lead to dopamine deficiency and 3%-5% increased risk for schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, ADHD, depression,
and addictive disorders); 26% of population carries Val/Val genotype of COMT; Val/Val
genotypecarriers with normal birth weight not at increased risk for conduct disorder or ADHD (2.5-fold increased
risk in carriers with low birth weight); carriers who use marijuana at 16% cumulative increased risk
for schizophreniform or psychotic reaction (no increased risk with Met/Met genotype)
|
 | Monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) genotype: low-expression variantphysical abuse increases risk for violent
crime and psychopathology (statistically significant decreased risk seen in absence of exposure to physical
abuse); high-expression variantphysical abuse not shown to increase risk for violent crimes
|
| Environmental influences: important to modify environment; encourage activities, eg, sports, playing music,
reading; watching television and playing video games shown to increase expression of aggression; gene
reactivitychildren with short/short genotype (of serotonin transporter gene) and abusive mothers shown to
have 80% chance for depression, but lowest overall risk for depression if mothers nurturing; people with short/
short genotype tend not to respond to serotonin agents, but respond to social support; physiology can be changed
by genes and environment; medical conditions influenced by multiple genetic and environmental factors
|
| Family-based approach: child behavior checklistallows parents to categorize children; helps assess conduct
disorder, ADHD, thought problems (eg, obsessive-compulsive disorder [OCD]), social problems, somatic complaints,
anxiety, depression, and bipolar disorder; estimates environmental influences; child psychiatric disorders
influenced by genetic and environmental factors and associated with suffering; children with psychiatric
disorder have mother or father with increased risk for adult form of condition (important to manage well-being
of parents); discuss with parents that helping them helps their child; teach parents how to, eg, use time-outs,
actively ignore, encourage reading, avoid television; study found that treatment of depressed mothers improved
various problems in children who were not treated
|
| Conclusion: treat psychopathology across pedigree with goal of diminishing influence of negative environment;
use common environmental approaches (eg, sports, music, family cohesion); use wellness paradigms (eg, encourage
family to exercise together); keep the well well; protect those at risk and intervene on behalf of those
who are ill; emphasize importance of family
|
Eating Disorders in a Primary Care Setting
David C. Rettew, MD, Assistant Professor of Psychiatry and Pediatrics, University of Vermont College of Medicine,
Burlington, and Erica Bove, Fourth Year Medical Student, University of Vermont College of Medicine
| Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) criteria for eating disorders
(EDs): fear of gaining weight; disturbance in way body weight or shape experienced; missing ≥3 consecutive
menstrual cycles
|
| Complexity of EDs: binge-eating and purging subtype of anorexia; malnourished state can cause symptoms
(many behavioral); can be difficult to determine underlying psychopathology and additional burden of malnutrition;
often clinically manifests as severe illness, followed by rapid turnaround as first round of symptoms due to
malnutrition eliminated
|
| Epidemiology: common; increasing incidence in western countries; incidence of EDs increases as countries become
westernized; occurs in higher socioeconomic groups
|
| Course and prognosis: onset often during adolescence (may be earlier with anorexia); many patients improve;
one-third of patients do well for long time, then relapse occasionally; some patients with chronic illness require
repeated psychiatric and medical hospitalization; mortality with anorexia, 10% (may be somewhat overestimated;
rate lower for bulimia)
|
| Triggers: teasing; most patients can describe specific comment made by, eg, parent, coach, peer
|
| Genetics: not uncommon for patient with anorexia to have parent with ED other than anorexia; genetic influence
in early adolescence (≈11 yr of age) low, then increases during teenage years; molecular studies currently inconclusive;
multiple genes likely to contribute small amount of risk; highest level of maladaptive eating attitudes
found in female twins with female co-twin (vs male co-twin; suggests possible role of prenatal factors)
|
| Families and media: influential family dynamicsfamilies with difficulty tolerating negative feelings and emotions;
rule-minded and competitive families; families with high supervision and control, with low affection and
warmth (classic pattern in EDs); televisionstudy conducted on island in which television newly introduced
found strong changes in perceptions of body shape in adolescent girls; Internetsome Web sites contain content
that condones or encourages EDs (eg, pictures of thin models, tricks on how to hide ED from parents); negative
comments in chat rooms (eg, youre a traitor) in response to those who say they may need to seek help;
parents often unaware of amount of time adolescents spend on Web sites
|
| Ericas experience: goal of recovery to have healthy relationship with food and exercise; complexity of EDs associated
with disordered patterns of thinking (eg, I lived somewhere between anorexia and bulimia; I did not
fit into a category); difficult for health care providers to intervene, due to scheduling and high volume of patients;
access to resources important
|
 | Background: Erica grew up in high-achieving prominent family in small town; perfectionist personality (eg,
never feeling good enough; she felt need to challenge self to next level); others in community involved in
extracurricular activities and school, but ED was the one area of my life that nobody else had control over;
Erica remained in cycle of purging through high school (although painful, theres a certain comfort to it);
participated on running team (vomiting after practicing hard affirmed by coaches and team [may have contributed
to onset of ED]); tried to stop purging; kept calorie count and negative ideas (eg, youre not good
enough) in head at all times
|
 | Recovery: in college, Erica became involved with support group (eg, therapist, dietitian, body image support
group; met daily to undo patterns); however, Erica never approached primary nurse practitioner, due
to feelings of shame; creative ways to counter negative thoughts important (eg, keep notes in pocket);
reach out to family, friends, and support system; recognize spectrum of ED and impact of influences
|
 | Advice for clinicians: ask patients about EDs; assure confidentiality; maintain neutrality; look to patients support
system (eg, family, friends; management requires group effort); be aware of language (eg, congratulating
patient for low BMI); recognize patterns (eg, type A personality) early; avoid using numbers while speaking to
patients (patients sensitive to, eg, number of calories, number of miles run)
|
| Screening: important to ask about EDs, especially in vulnerable populations (approach supported by American
Academy of Pediatrics [AAP]); if concern about ED exists, likelihood of problem high; may be few or no physical
findings on examination; check bone density; comorbidities include depression and OCD (may be as or
more treatable than ED)
|
| Management approach: generate motivation to change; correct underlying problems; assemble treatment team
of pediatrician, psychiatrist, and dietitian
|
| Treatment and recovery: weight gainshould be slow (eg, 0.5 lb/wk); weight gain of 2 to 3 lb/wk can horrify
patients and lead to relapse; psychotherapymore research in adolescents needed; Maudsley method of using
food as medicine (parents assume initial control; then, control transferred to patient); cognitive behavior therapy
(CBT)shown effective in adults (particularly for bulimia); psychopharmacologyno highly effective medications
for core symptoms of anorexia; selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) effective for bulimia; bupropion
(eg, Wellbutrin) contraindicated in people who purge, due to increased risk for seizures; olanzapine
antipsychotic drug associated with weight gain; used in some studies because patients level of obsessiveness
and body dissatisfaction appeared slightly psychotic and delusional; other studies showed weight gain short-
lived and followed by relapse
|
| Levels of care: range from outpatient care to medical intensive care unit (ICU); not uncommon to navigate
through system as patients improve or worsen; good communication important for avoiding split of the team
(eg, some clinicians clear on therapy being about food and weight, other therapists feel, we dont even talk
about weight unless we have to); strong opinions can result in patient choosing sides; declare team captain, or
clarify need for consistency (eg, establish weight goals, amount of focus on weight, criteria for intensive settings,
amount of family involvement, and out-of-appointment contacts); hospitalizationspecialized units have
dedicated protocols for supervised meals, privileges, and weight gain
|
Suggested Reading
Eley TC et al: Gene-environment interaction analysis of serotonin system markers with adolescent depression. Mol Psychiatry
9:908, 2004; Grilo CM et al: Natural course of bulimia nervosa and of eating disorder not otherwise specified: 5-year prospective
study of remissions, relapses, and the effects of personality disorder psychopathology. J Clin Psychiatry 68:738, 2007;
Hudziak JJ et al: A dimensional approach to developmental psychopathology. Int J Methods Psychiatr Res 16 Suppl 1
2007:S16, 2007; Hudziak JJ et al: The genetic and environmental contributions to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder as
measured by the Conners' Rating Scales--Revised. Am J Psychiatry 162:1614, 2005; Hudziak JJ: Developmental Psychopathology
and Wellness: Genetic and Environmental Influences. American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc. 2008; Lamberg
L: Advances in eating disorders offer food for thought. JAMA 290:1437, 2003; Martin A et al: Mission statement: advancing
the science of pediatric mental health and promoting the care of youth and their families. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
47:1, 2008; Meyer-Lindenberg A et al: Impact of complex genetic variation in COMT on human brain function. Mol Psychiatry
11:867, 2006; Mitchell JE et al: Scope and significance of eating disorders. J Consult Clin Psychol 55:628, 1987;
Rettew DC et al: Associations between temperament and DSM-IV externalizing disorders in children and adolescents. J Dev
Behav Pediatr 25:383, 2004; Rettew DC: In this issue/abstract thinking: media and children's mental health. J Am Acad
Child Adolesc Psychiatry 47:479, 2008; Shaw P et al: Intellectual ability and cortical development in children and adolescents.
Nature 440:676, 2006; Thiel A et al: Thirty-month outcome in patients with anorexia or bulimia nervosa and concomitant
obsessive-compulsive disorder. Am J Psychiatry 155:244, 1998.
|