PRIMARY MANAGEMENT OF ANXIETY AND DEPRESSION
From An Intensive Review of Family Medicine, presented by the Medical University of South Carolina, June 2008
John R. Freedy, MD, PhD, Assistant Professor, Department of Family Medicine, and Director, Behavioral Science
Curriculum, Trident Family Medicine Residency Program, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston
Educational Objectives
| The goal of this program is to improve the management of depression and anxiety disorders in adults and children.
After hearing and assimilating this program, the clinician will be better able to:
|
 | Describe the collaborative care model for the management of depression.
|
 | Determine safety and efficacy of using antidepressant therapy for depression after stroke and depression in
pregnancy.
|
 | Discuss diagnostic features, prevalence, and comorbidities of other anxiety disorders.
|
 | Select safe and effective treatment of depression in children.
|
 | Counsel children and adolescents about suicide and anxiety disorders.
|
Faculty Disclosure
In adherence to ACCME Standards for Commercial Support, Audio-Digest requires all faculty and members of the planning
committee to disclose relevant financial relationships within the past 12 months that might create any personal conflicts
of interest. Any identified conflicts were resolved to ensure that this educational activity promotes quality in health
care and not a proprietary business or commercial interest. For this program, Dr. Freedy and the planning committee reported
nothing to disclose.
Acknowledgements
Dr. Freedy spoke in Kiawah Island, SC, at An Intensive Review of Family Medicine, presented June 9-14, 2008, by the
Medical University of South Carolina. The Audio-Digest Foundation thanks Dr. Freedy and the Medical University
of South Carolina for their cooperation in the production of this program.
Primary Care Management of Adult Depression and Anxiety
| Symptoms of depression: sleep disturbance; change in interest level; guilty feelings; energy reduction; concentration reduction;
appetite changes; psychomotor symptoms (eg, retardation, agitation); suicidal thoughts; patients must have ≥5
symptoms (one symptom must be depressed mood or anhedonia [loss of pleasure])
|
| Categories of depression: major depressive disorder (MDD); dysthymic disorder (low-grade depression; lasts ≥2 yr); adjustment
disorder (associated with specific stressor; lasts ≤6 mo); mood disorder due to general medical condition; substance-induced
mood disorder; bereavement
|
| Epidemiology: common; lifetime rate, 17%; current rate in US adults, 2% to 4%; more common (2:1) in women than in
men; not related to ethnicity, education, or socioeconomic or marital status; 1.5 to 3.0 times more common in first-degree
relatives; average age at onset, 20 to 30 yr; patients with history of one episode of MDD have ≤60% chance for second
episode (after 2 episodes, 70% chance for third episode; after ≥3 episodes, 90% chance for subsequent episode); rates of
MDD differ between practice settings (eg, rates higher in inpatient settings compared to outpatient settings)
|
| Atypical antipsychotic agents and bipolar disorder: 5% to 10% of time, unipolar depression progresses to bipolar depression
(bipolar III disorder; medication-induced mania); rare
|
| Comorbidities: current MDD, past MDD, and severe medical illness associated with increased mortality; other health risks
and behaviors (eg, tobacco smoking, alcohol abuse, obesity)
|
| Listening to patients: physicians perspectivevaluable; may be difficult due to time constraints; fear of Pandoras Box
(eg, I cant address that because the person will fall apart or be in my office for a long time); patients perspective
physicians listen less now; patients seek out providers who listen; study concluded that treatment of depression must include
listening, screening, medications, and referral; findings of study of 15 patients with depression in past yearmost
primary care providers did not ask about depression and did not use past depression as cue to screen for current depression;
most patients received limited information and treatment options; patients lacked motivation to seek information independently;
limited collaboration between physicians and patients on treatment decisions
|
| Screening: United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends screening for adults and competent follow-up;
your choice to screen children and adolescents; meta-analysis found single-item screening questionnaire as effective
as others (sensitivity ≥80%)
|
| Collaborative care model: based on concept of chronic disease management; group practices placed in collaborative care
conditions; primary care provider initiates referral for depression; case manager (trained midlevel provider) follows patients
(eg, places telephone calls, assesses depression and medication adherence); mental health professional provides weekly supervision;
requires education (eg, 1-2 hr of continuing medical education) at beginning of project, and every 3 to 6 mo thereafter;
benefitspatients more likely to begin, adhere to, and complete treatment; higher measures of life satisfaction and
function; patients more likely to be working after 12 mo; physicians more likely to conclude that depression can be managed
in primary care settings (getting around Pandoras Box); depression more likely to resolve or improve, compared to
usual care (40%-50% vs 25%-40%); comorbid depression with chronic physical conditions can be successfully managed;
improved quality of depression care; cost-neutral if not cost-effective
|
| Depression after stroke: occurs in ≈20% of hospitalized patients and 20% to 25% of ambulatory patients; functional rehabilitation
and cognitive function poor; increases 1-yr and 10-yr mortality; antidepressantsimprove depression, cognitive
function, and general function; 2 in 3 randomized controlled trials show reduced likelihood of subsequent stroke and
death within 6 to 24 mo
|
| Depression and myocardial infarction (MI): depression increases risk for first MI; uncertain whether treatment of depression
prevents first MI; depression after MI increases likelihood of subsequent MI and death; safe to treat depression with
selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), but uncertain whether effects similar to those of treating patients with
stroke; some studies found use of antidepressant in tobacco smokers with depression after MI reduced recurrence of MI
|
| Treatment of depression in pregnancy: older studies do not support connection between tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs)
and birth defects; newer studies suggest increased risk (eg, lower birth weight, preterm birth, fetal death, seizures, discontinuation
syndrome) to infants with some SSRIs (particularly agents with shorter half-lives); paroxetine (Paxil; category
D); fluoxetine (eg, Prozac) typically recommended (if youre going to use something, thats probably the safest); problem
rates low; study designs do not allow inference of causality (most studies retrospective cohort studies); similar adverse
outcome rates associated with untreated depression during pregnancy; history of depression major risk factor for
relapse (relapse rate in pregnancy, 43%-66% [depending on continuation of medication]); lactationmaternal serum
levels of antidepressant drugs low; some studies suggest maternal depression can adversely affect child development; recommend
taking medications at night (breast-feeding during day, and bottle-feeding at night)
|
| Panic disorder: featuresrecurrent or unexpected panic attacks; ≥1 mo of worry about having another attack; behavioral
changes (eg, avoidance); prevalencelifetime rate, 1% to 2% (10%-30% in medical settings); comorbidities
depression; other anxiety disorders; treatmentSSRIs and TCAs equally effective; cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
and medications equally effective; unclear whether combining psychotherapy with medications (clinical rule of thumb)
more effective
|
| Social phobia: featuresintense persistent fear and immediate anxiety associated with social or performance situations; person
recognizes response irrational, but just cant seem to help [him or her]self; avoidance of situations or facing situations
with dread; prevalencelifetime rate, ≤13%; 85% of patients experience academic or occupational difficulties;
comorbiditiesdepression; other anxiety disorders; substance abuse; treatmentSSRIs; monoamine oxidase inhibitors
(MAOIs); benzodiazepines; β-blockers for performance anxiety; 75% improvement with CBT (fewer relapses than with
medication); uncertain whether combination treatment more effective than medication or CBT alone
|
| Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD): featuresrecurrent obsessions or compulsions; severity causes marked distress;
obsessive behavior for >1 hr/day; person recognizes behavior as unreasonable or excessive but cant help yourself; onset
in boys and men, 13 yr of age to young adulthood (in women, 20-30 yr of age); long-term course of waxing and waning;
prevalencelifetime rate in community samples, ≤50%; comorbiditiesdepression; anxiety; tics; Tourettes
syndrome; treatmentSSRIs (higher doses than those used to treat depression); 8 to 12 wk for complete response; uncertain
whether combined therapy more effective; speaker prefers using combined therapy (discuss with patient)
|
| Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD): featurestraumatic life event; ≥1 re-experiencing symptom (eg, flashback, nightmare);
avoidance and emotional numbing; physiologic arousal (eg, jumpiness, anxiety, insomnia); prevalencelifetime rate,
8%; in primary care samples, 10% to 20%; current lifetime rates, ≤33% (condition may be underidentified); comorbidities
depression and other anxiety disorders; health risk behaviors (eg, tobacco smoking, alcohol abuse, obesity); treatment
SSRIs; other antidepressants; benzodiazepines; mood stabilizers; atypical antipsychotic agents; eye movement desensitization
|
| Questions and answers: β-blockersuseful for patients with performance anxiety, but not particularly useful for patients
with PTSD; PTSDafter traumatic life event, stress debriefing (discussing and processing event) does not appear to prevent
development of PTSD; use of medications (eg, β-blockers, SSRIs) reasonable, but has not panned out in terms of
research; lifetime rate of depression17% in community samples (doubled in ambulatory settings); suicidality95%
of people who commit suicide have mental health issue; risks include personal family history of suicide attempts, genetics,
precipitating events (eg, loss of job), and lethality of means
|
Primary Care Management of Pediatric Depression and Anxiety
| Management characteristics of family physician: strong sense of responsibility; ability to assist patients in coping with
everyday problems and in maintaining stability in family and community
|
| Normal fears and developmental issues: infantsloud noises; easy startling; anxiety around strangers; toddlers
imaginary creatures (eg, boogeyman); fear of dark; separation anxiety; school-aged childrenworry about injuries; fear of
natural events (eg, thunderstorms); older children and teenagersanxiety about school performance; social competence (eg,
appearance); health issues (eg, awareness of self and development)
|
| Screening recommendations: USPSTF suggests insufficient evidence about whether issues (eg, substance use, depression,
suicide, contraception) should be discussed with children, teenagers, and young adults; other agencies (eg, American
Academy of Family Physicians [AAFP]) suggest reasonable to screen for issues at appropriate times
|
| Cognitive development: abstract thinking and understanding of cause and effect (eg, consequences of tobacco smoking)
develops in adolescence; ability for abstract thinking and number of risky behaviors increases in late adolescence
|
| Assessment: American Medical Associations Guidelines for Adolescent Preventive Services (GAPS) questionnaire
multiple forms available (eg, adolescent-directed, parent-focused; English or Spanish); covers medical history, family information,
related health issues, and health profile (eg, eating, violence, tobacco use); asks about concerns; caring for
adolescentsoffer chance to be examined and counseled separately from parent or guardian; make reasonable effort to
encourage adolescent to involve parents and guardians in health care decisions; educate parents to encourage adolescents
to take personal responsibility in health care; facilitate communication about appointments and payments; discuss and
maintain confidentiality
|
| Childhood depression: criteriaaccording to Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition
(DSM-IV); ≥5 symptoms occur during 2-wk period; decline from previous functioning; depressed mood or loss of interest
or pleasure; consider childs ability to articulate symptoms; symptomsdepressed mood; irritability; diminished interest
or pleasure; boredom; weight loss or gain; insomnia or hypersomnia; agitation or retardation; fatigue; worthlessness;
guilt; attention or concentration difficulties; thoughts of death; stomachaches; headaches; consider functional impairments
(eg, relationships with peers); rule out substance abuse, bereavement, and bipolar disorder
|
| Risk factors: chronic illness; female sex (2:1); hormonal changes; positive family history; serotonin transporter gene (long/
short or short/short genotypes); childhood neglect or abuse; stressors (eg, moving); loss of loved one, parent, or romantic
relationship; anxiety disorder; attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD); conduct or learning disorders; alcohol or
drug abuse; tobacco smoking; history of depression
|
| Comorbidities: anxiety disorders; disruptive behavior disorders; substance abuse; 1 in 5 may develop bipolar disorder; adolescents
with bipolar disorderADHD; conduct disorder; anxiety disorder
|
| Psychotherapy: CBT effective for mild to moderate childhood depression; physician-based counselingeducation about
healthy coping skills, problem solving, conflict resolution, social and assertiveness skills, and relaxation techniques; educate
parents about realistic age-appropriate expectations and appropriate communication strategies; support healthy behaviors,
psychologic defenses, and relationships; listen to teenagers (as an ally)
|
| Medications: TCAs ineffective for depression and anxiety in children (limited effectiveness in adolescents); SSRIs have strongest
(but still somewhat limited) evidence for effectiveness (highest efficacy in patients ≥13 yr of age); studies using SSRIs
often flawed (eg, high placebo response rates, and no statistical power to evaluate suicidality); meta-analysislooked at pediatric
trials using antidepressants to treat depression, OCD, or other anxiety disorders; medications included SSRIs, nefazodone,
venlafaxine (Effexor), and mirtazapine (Remeron); outcomes of interest included response status, reduction in
depression scores, and suicidal ideations and attempts; number needed to treat (NNT) for MDD, 10 (NNT for OCD, 6; NNT
for other anxiety disorders, 3); compared to other treatments, this is as good as it gets for efficacy; SSRIs and newer antidepressants
effective in teenagers; number needed to harm, 143; fluoxetine preferred choice for children <13 yr of age; carefully
weigh risks and benefits; weekly follow-up recommended for first month of antidepressant use (every other week for
second month; assess for subsequent follow-up); length of treatmentfor first episode of depression, 6 mo of treatment;
≥12 mo for second episode; 1 to 3 yr for third episode
|
| Suicidality: extremely rare before puberty; third leading cause of death in persons 10- to 24-yr of age; risk factorsmental
health disorder; precipitating event; previous attempts predict subsequent attempts; positive family history of attempt; boys
more likely to successfully commit suicide; identity issues (eg, sexuality); hopelessness; suicide preventionphysician
education about recognition and treatment of depression; restriction of lethal means (eg, weapons, medications); ask about
suicidality and mood; be direct, reassuring, and nonjudgmental; reduce stress; mitigate risk factors; treat depression or
other mental health problem (including substance abuse); consider hospitalization or crisis stabilization services; do not
prescribe potentially lethal medications; do not let fear of bad outcome impair ability to assess and treat patients
|
| Generalized anxiety disorder: featuresexcessive worry; other issues (eg, fatigue, muscle tension, sleep disturbance) occur
chronically (≥6 mo); affects 3% to 5% of adolescents; comorbidities include other mental health disorders; treatment
CBT; SSRIs may be helpful; frequent visits for reassurance
|
| Social phobia: featuresmarked and persistent fear of ≥1 social or performance situations; children do not recognize response
as unreasonable; shyness may precede social phobia; comorbidities include other mental health disorders and substance
abuse; treatment β-blockers for performance-based issues
|
| Obsessive-compulsive disorder: onset for boys typically earlier than in girls; 50% of adolescents with OCD have other
anxiety disorders (eg, depression, tics)
|
| Posttraumatic stress disorder: traumatic event related to fear, helplessness, or horror; re-experiencing symptoms; avoidance
and emotional numbing; patients jumpy and easily startled; functional impairment; symptoms last >30 days
|
| Questions and answers: confidentialitycan be breached if patient poses danger to self or others; talk with patients to assess
abstract thinking ability, coping ability, or stability of home situation; behavior therapyassign positive activities (eg, exercise);
prescribing antidepressant alone incomplete management of depression
|
Suggested Reading
Antonuccio D: Treating depressed children with antidepressants: more harm than benefit? J Clin Psychol Med Settings
15:92, 2008; Emslie GJ: Pediatric anxiety--underrecognized and undertreated. N Engl J Med 359:2835, 2008; Jack MS et
al: Situational panic attacks: impact on distress and impairment among patients with social phobia. Depress Anxiety10:112,
1999; Johnston O et al: Qualitative study of depression management in primary care: GP and patient goals, and the value
of listening. Br J Gen Pract 57:872, 2007; Kendrick T et al: GP treatment decisions for patients with depression: an observational
study. Br J Gen Pract 55:280, 2005; Möller HJ et al: Do SSRIs or antidepressants in general increase suicidality?
WPA Section on Pharmacopsychiatry: consensus statement. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 258 Suppl 3:3, 2008; Otto
MW et al: Childhood history of anxiety disorders among adults with social phobia: rates, correlates, and comparisons with
patients with panic disorder. Depress Anxiety 14:209, 2001; Richardson L et al: Collaborative care for adolescent depression:
a pilot study. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 31:36, 2009; Saver BG et al: A qualitative study of depression in primary care:
missed opportunities for diagnosis and education. J Am Board Fam Med 20:28, 2007; Seemüller F et al: Antidepressants
and suicidality in younger adults--is bipolar illness the missing link? Acta Psychiatr Scand 119:166; author reply 167, 2009;
Smith JL et al: Developing a national dissemination plan for collaborative care for depression: QUERI Series. Implement
Sci 3:59, 2008; Storr CL et al: Childhood antecedents of exposure to traumatic events and posttraumatic stress disorder.
Am J Psychiatry 164:119, 2007; Williams JW Jr et al: Is this patient clinically depressed? JAMA 287:1160, 2002.
|