CAUTION: MIND FIELDS!
Educational Objectives
| The goal of this program is to improve recognition and management of personality and eating disorders. After hearing
and assimilating this program, the clinician will be better able to:
|
 | Describe the behavioral patterns associated with paranoid, narcissistic, antisocial, and borderline personality
disorders.
|
 | Utilize the most effective communication strategies when treating patients with personality disorders.
|
 | Implement screening questions to help identify patients with eating disorders.
|
 | Detail the common signs, symptoms, and laboratory findings associated with eating disorders.
|
 | Discuss the role of medical therapy in the management of patients with personality disorders or eating disorders.
|
Faculty Disclosure
In adherence to ACCME Standards for Commercial Support, Audio-Digest requires all faculty and members of the planning
committee to disclose relevant financial relationships within the past 12 months that might create any personal conflicts
of interest. Any identified conflicts were resolved to ensure that this educational activity promotes quality in health
care and not a proprietary business or commercial interest. For this program, the faculty and planning committee reported
nothing to disclose.
Acknowledgments
Dr. Servis was recorded at Primary Care Psychiatry Update, sponsored by UC Davis Health System, Office of Continuing
Medical Education and Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, and held January 10, 2009, in Sacramento,
CA; Dr. Woods was recorded at Facing and Managing Change in Family Medicine, sponsored by Maryland
Academy of Family Physicians, and held June 25-28, 2008, in Cumberland, MD. The Audio-Digest Foundation
thanks the speakers and the sponsors for their cooperation in the production of this program.
Personality Disorders: Can These Even be Treated?
Mark E. Servis MD, Professor and Vice Chair for Education, and Roy Brophy Endowed Chair, Department of Psychiatry
and Behavioral Sciences, University of California, Davis, School of Medicine, Sacramento
| Challenges posed by patients with personality disorders: interactions require significant time and energy; patients often
use extortion and manipulation (including self-destructive behaviors and threats of self-injury); idealization and
devaluation of caregivers (patients often scorn past clinicians while lavishing praise on current clinician; opinions
quickly oscillate between extremes); anaclitic dependency; countertransference (patients evoke powerful feelings [eg,
anger, frustration] in others)
|
| Personality and personality disorders: personalityan individuals behavioral patterns for managing internal and external
conflicts; personality disorderresults when individual exclusively relies on one set of coping skills or defenses
|
| General considerations: trait- vs state-dependentbehavior patterns persistent and consistent (ie, not dependent on
emotional state); state-based phenomena must be ruled out before making diagnosis of personality disorder;
pervasivebehavior patterns present in all situations and environments; ego-syntonicdisorder does not cause internal
distress or discomfort, so patients generally do not seek help on own
|
| Paranoid personality disorder: patients view world as hostile and dangerous, and therefore become hypervigilant, suspicious,
mistrustful, and guarded; paranoid thoughts likely represent unconscious projection of own feelings or internal
conflicts; thoughts not psychotic or delusional (ie, have basis in reality); management strategies in primary careavoid
ridicule or pointing out errors in patients thinking; maintain professional distance and neutral position; avoid befriending
patient in effort to convince or direct patient; be consistent; avoid power struggles; remain genuine and truthful
|
 | Case: man, 52 yr of age, claims pharmacist intentionally switched medication prescribed for erectile dysfunction; became
suspicious when pharmacist treated him rudely; patient guarded, suspicious, and mistrustful in relationships
(personal and professional)
|
 | Approach: strategies to avoidpsychoanalysis (patients resistant to psychotherapy); lying (eg, telling patient that he
is probably right); confronting patient or challenging his view; recommended strategyremain genuine; listen attentively;
circumvent problem (eg, recommend patient go to different pharmacy) without validating claim
|
| Narcissistic personality disorder: grandiose persona but easily injured and very sensitive to criticism (individual may
become suicidal in wake of harsh criticism); shallow and labile affect; grandiosity protects fragile self-esteem; limited
capacity for empathy; self-absorbed, entitled attitude; management strategies in primary caregain trust and
cooperation by giving patient positive reinforcement and praise; maintain idealized transference; avoid criticism;
notedepression quickly resolves when patient praised and complimented
|
 | Case: man, 57 yr of age, admitted to hospital for elective coronary artery bypass; demands special treatment and privileges
and wants to know what privileges other patients have received; repeatedly boasts about career and personal
importance; refuses preoperative blood work (blood work had been performed recently; patient insists that others
have not needed preoperative blood work); wife reports persistence and pervasiveness of behavior
|
 | Approach: recommended strategypraise patient for his patience and negotiate for adherence; strategies to avoid
coercing patient into adherence; changing staff or moving patient to different department; educating patient about
hospital policies (ineffective)
|
| Antisocial personality disorder: individuals lack conscience and do not experience guilt or remorse; chronically exploit
others for self-gratification (possibly sadistic); approachprotect self and staff; set clear limits on behavior; provide
explicit and consistent rewards and consequences, based on behavior; this approach most effective when
situational variables controlled
|
| Borderline personality disorder: arrested development of identity (patients similar to adolescents in many ways), resulting in
identity diffusion and feelings of emptiness; patients often experiment with different identities; relationships unstable and
characterized by manipulation and dependence; idealization and devaluation common (may occur almost simultaneously),
and likely reflects dichotomous self-image (ie, good self and bad self); characterized by mood instability, aggression,
and chronic depression; self-destructive behaviorscommonly used as means of manipulation (especially as response to
abandonment); patients at increased risk for suicide; other common behaviors include superficial cutting (patients report
feeling relief after intentionally cutting selves); dependencepatients often very social and cannot tolerate being alone;
impulsivitysubstance abuse and destructive sexual behaviors common; borderline psychosispatients may become transiently
psychotic when under stress; violencetypically self-directed
|
| Management issues for patients with borderline personality disorder: comorbid axis-I disorders (eg, mood disorders,
substance abuse) require treatment; medical management helps improve axis-I disorders and behaviors associated with
primary personality disorder; medicationsselective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) dampen destructive behaviors;
mood stabilizers decrease impulsivity in most patients; low-dose antipsychotic agents prevent episodes of psychosis
in vulnerable patients
|
 | Case: woman, 27 yr of age, reports 2-day history of depression and suicidal thoughts (incited by relationship ending);
medical history includes psychiatric treatment, mood stabilizers, and antidepressants, but patient not currently taking
medications (claims absence of efficacy); interview reveals tendency for idealization and devaluation; superficial
lacerations on arms (only unusual finding on physical examination; patient admits self-infliction); mental status
examination identifies labile mood and passive suicidal ideation, but no delusions
|
 | Approach: recommended strategyset limits on self-destructive behavior; involve collateral caregivers to diffuse transference;
strategies to avoid using positive reinforcement to encourage patient (unlikely to have lasting effect);
building intimacy in relationship to establish trust (dangerous); exploring patients history to identify incidence of sexual
abuse (common, but should be addressed only in context of long-term psychotherapy); other management tips
establish time limits and explicit treatment plan; avoid capitulating to patients demands (eg, for more time); encourage
patient to express feelings through words rather than behaviors; beware of idealization
|
| Managing personality disorders: long-term psychotherapeutic approaches effective, especially in borderline and narcissistic
patients; patients with certain severe disorders (eg, sociopathic, malignant narcissistic, schizotypal personality
disorders) do not respond to treatment
|
| Questions and answers: nature vs nurturegenetic and environmental factors; childhood trauma important, but increasing
evidence for genetic predisposition; cure vs managementlifelong illness, but some psychotherapies very effective
(especially for patients with borderline personality disorder); use of opioidsuse nonopioid analgesics when possible;
avoid use in patients with antisocial personality disorder
|
Eating Disorders: A Primer for Family Practice
Brenda K. Woods, MD, Director of Medical Services, Remuda Center for Eating Disorders, Milford, VA
| Introduction: eating disorders common but often not diagnosed; diverse population, many of whom do not fit stereotypes;
disorders often begin at young age; 40% of third-grade girls, and 75% of fifth-grade girls, diet to lose weight
|
| Anorexia nervosa: low body weight (≤85th percentile), including (in growing children) failure to gain weight; intense
fear of gaining weight or becoming overweight; negative body image; primary amenorrhea or ≥3 mo of secondary
amenorrhea (note, patients taking oral contraceptives may continue to menstruate, despite low body mass index
[BMI]); subtypesrestrictive; binge-purge
|
| Bulimia: patient binge-eats ≥2 times/week for ≥3 mo and experiences remorse after binging; compensatory behaviors
after binge (eg, vomiting, laxative abuse, compulsive exercise, fasting); negative body image
|
| Eating disorder not otherwise specified (NOS): eating disorder significant, but falls outside definitions of anorexia and
bulimia; examplespatient has very low body weight but does not exhibit amenorrhea; patient has lost large amount
of weight but is not underweight
|
| Obesity: although obese individuals often compulsively overeat, obesity not considered eating disorder in Diagnostic
and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition
|
| Prevalence: ≈15% of women 14 to 30 yr of age; ≈12% of all women; 4% of men; ie, 5 to 10 million women and ≈1 million
men in United States have diagnosable eating disorders
|
| Early intervention: when possible, engage and treat patients before severe emaciation occurs; important to screen,
monitor, and engage patients with low or falling weight; evidencemost practice recommendations supported by
level C evidence; because research requirements dictate use of populations free of comorbid psychiatric diagnoses,
difficult to recruit sufficient numbers of patients for clinical trials
|
| Diagnosis: patients rarely seek help for eating disorder; disorders surrounded by shame and denial (similar to substance
abuse); screening questionshow do you feel about your weight? (often associated with strong emotions); how often
do you weigh yourself? (some patients never check weight [afraid they may have gained weight]; others check weight
many times each day); how much has your weight fluctuated lately? (vomiting or laxative abuse may result in wide
daily fluctuations in weight); do you feel out of control when you eat? (patients with anorexia often report loss of control,
even when eating very little; binge-eating defined by loss of control); do you ever do anything to eliminate or burn
off what you have eaten? are other people concerned about your weight or how you eat?
|
| Associated signs and symptoms: weight loss of uncertain etiologyrule out other causes of weight loss, but remember to
screen for eating disorder; primary or secondary amenorrheafirst rule out pregnancy; chronic constipation or
diarrheaask patients about laxative use; study showed that 20% of patients who had been referred to gastroenterologist
for chronic diarrhea abused laxatives (ie, had undiagnosed eating disorder); general symptomsdizziness; fatigue;
gastrointestinal symptomschronic sore throat or gastroesophageal reflux (caused by vomiting); repeated vomiting increases
risk for Barretts esophagus and other complications associated with reflux; infertilitycommon reason for
seeking medical advice; physical findings associated with vomitingenlarged parotid and submandibular glands (may
become more pronounced 1-2 days after vomiting); cavities and eroded enamel (evident after ≈2 yr of chronic vomiting);
angular cheilosis (gastric contents irritate soft tissues of mouth; may signal vitamin deficiency); energypatients report
high levels of energy despite cachectic appearance; other physical findingsgrowth of lanugo hair; chronic hypotension,
bradycardia, and/or hypothermia; edema (caused by rebound retention of fluid after purging)
|
| Laboratory findings: hypercholesterolemiaimportant to screen for eating disorder (affects management); etiology
poorly understood; insufficient intake of foods that promote breakdown of cholesterol may lead to gradual increase
in serum levels of cholesterol; patients need to introduce fats and proteins into diet; leukopeniacaused by bone-
marrow suppression; corrected QT intervalmay be prolonged; associated with disturbances in electrolytes; enzyme
abnormalitiesstarvation associated with elevations in liver enzymes; vomiting may result in elevated levels
of serum amylase; lipase levels may increase (associated with pancreatitis); electrolyte disturbanceshyponatremia
(caused by increased intake of fluids; patients may drink large volumes of, eg, water, in effort to suppress hunger); hypokalemia
(commonly associated with vomiting or laxative abuse); urine specific gravity may increase (ketones
present) if patients restrict intake of fluid; metabolic disturbancesmetabolic acidosis (caused by vomiting); elevation
or suppression of thyrotropin (screen for eating disorder before treating hypothyroidism)
|
| Medication caution: patients at risk for QT abnormalities; avoid medications that affect QT interval
|
| Malnourishment: serum albuminlevel usually normal (in contrast to patients with chronic medical conditions);
diagnosisassess body composition or BMI, and percentage of ideal body weight; may see depressed levels of prealbumin,
and evidence of iron deficiency and/or neutropenia
|
| Associated behaviors: various combinations of restriction, binging, purging (vomiting; abuse of laxatives or diuretics),
stimulant abuse, and compulsive exercising; less common behaviors include chewing and spitting (ie, not swallowing
food), eating nonnutritive items (eg, paper, cotton), and (in children) refusal to swallow saliva; preoccupation with
food or obsessive calorie counting
|
| Agents of abuse: ipecacevokes vomiting; cardiotoxic and causes peripheral myopathy; available over-the-counter;
prescription diet pillseasily available via Internet; stimulantscaffeine; methamphetamines; cocaine
|
| Management approach: basic evaluationweigh patients in hospital gown (underwear only; empty bladder); perform
dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) for patients with 6 to 12 mo of amenorrhea (patients at risk for osteoporosis);
management teamphysician (case manager); dietician; therapist; psychiatrist; weight gainslowly
increase intake of food (dangerous to increase intake too quickly); inpatient programs strive to increase weight by 2
to 3 lb per week; 1 lb/wk good goal in outpatient programs; therapeutic issueseating disorders serve purpose
by addressing unmet emotional need (ie, not directly related to food, weight, or appearance); identifying purpose
and redirecting behavior important part of recovery; medical managementfluoxetine (60 mg) beneficial for treating
patients with bulimia; other psychopharmacologic agents appropriate for managing comorbid psychiatric disorders
|
Suggested Reading
Capasso A et al: Pharmacological profile of SSRIs and SNRIs in the treatment of eating disorders. Curr Clin
Pharmacol 4:78, 2009; Currin L et al: Primary care physicians knowledge of and attitudes toward the eating
disorders: Do they affect clinical actions? Int J Eat Disord Dec 29, 2008 [Epub ahead of print]; Fenichel RM,
Warren MP: Anorexia, bulimia, and the athletic triad: evaluation and management. Curr Osteoporos Rep 5:160,
2007; Freizinger M et al: The prevalence of eating disorders in infertile women. Fertil Steril Nov 10, 2008
[Epub ahead of print]; Haas LJ et al: Management of the difficult patient. Am Fam Physician 72:2063, 2005;
Kienast T, Foerster J: Psychotherapy of personality disorders and concomitant substance dependence. Curr
Opin Psychiatry 21:619, 2008; Lenzenweger MF: Epidemiology of personality disorders. Psychiatr Clin North
Am 31:395, 2008; Misra M: Long-term skeletal effects of eating disorders with onset in adolescence. Ann N Y
Acad Sci 1135:212, 2008; Mitchell JE et al: Health care utilization in patients with eating disorders. Int J Eat
Disord Jan 26, 2009 [Epub ahead of print]; Murdach AD: Negotiating with antisocial clients. Soc Work 53:179,
2008; Soeteman DI et al: The burden of disease in personality disorders: diagnosis-specific quality of life. J Pers
Disord 22:259, 2008; van Beek N, Verheul R: Motivation for treatment in patients with personality disorders. J
Pers Disord 22:89, 2008; Ward RK: Assessment and management of personality disorders. Am Fam Physician
70:1505, 2004.
|